How to choose between faction random and planet-type random

The quick difference

Faction random is the fastest path: every player receives an exact faction and can start planning immediately.

Planet-type random gives each player a home color/type first, then lets them choose from eligible factions later. It is better when people want surprise without losing all agency.

Use faction random when

The group wants a clean reveal, a fast setup, or a balanced teaching-night pool.

• You trust the selected faction pool.
• Players are comfortable adapting.
• The night is more about momentum than negotiation.

Use planet-type random when

Players like constraints but still want to make a final faction choice after looking at the table.

• You want to avoid duplicate home types.
• Some players dislike being locked into high-complexity factions.
• The table wants a small draft moment after setup.